Blog

2PL vs 3PL: Navigating the Logistics Landscape

determine whether a 3PL is right for you

  • Written by Ellie Kwon
  • Published on December 7, 2023
  • Time to read 9 minutes

People often use trucks or vans to move things from one place to another. Sometimes, they need help from companies that specialize in moving things around. Two types of companies can help, let’s discuss the pros and cons of each when it comes to 2PL vs 3PL. 

Second-Party Logistics: The Carrier

2PL stands for “second-party logistics.” These companies move things from point A to point B. They have their vehicles and drivers. These are the carriers. The freight companies and the transportation teams. They often are involved in the beginning stages of transport rather than the last mile. 

Third-Party Logistics: The All-In-one

3PL stands for “third-party logistics.” These companies do more than move things from one place to another. They provide extra services, like packing, storing, and managing inventory. They also use their trucks and drivers to move things. 

In summary, 2PL companies help move things from one place to another, while 3PL companies provide extra services like packing and storing.

2PL

Second-party logistics, or 2PL, refers to a type of logistics service where a company provides transportation and storage of goods using its own trucks, warehouses, and workforce.

3PL

Third-party logistics, or 3PL, refers to a type of logistics service where a company provides a range of services beyond the transportation and storage of goods. In addition to moving things from one place to another, they offer extra services like packing, crating, inventory management, and warehousing. 

3PL providers use trucks, warehouses, and personnel to offer these services. They can be hired to manage logistics, from transportation to storing and distributing goods. 3PL providers offer a comprehensive logistics solution for businesses that need to move and store their products efficiently.

A chart is shown, which lists the pros and cons of a 2pl vs 3pl.

2PL vs. 3PL

Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons when it comes to 2pl vs 3pl.

2PL Pros

Second-party logistics, or 2PL, can have its own set of pros and cons. Here are some of them.

Direct control

2PL providers use their equipment and personnel, offering more direct control over the transportation and storage of goods. This can be particularly useful for businesses with specific logistics operations requirements.

Cost-effective

2PL providers can be more cost-effective than 3PL providers since they only offer transportation and storage services. This can be helpful for businesses that have limited logistics needs.

Flexibility 

2PL providers can be more flexible than 3PL providers regarding scheduling and delivery options. 

2PL Cons

Limited services

2PL providers only offer transportation and storage services, so they cannot provide additional services like packing and inventory management. This can disadvantage businesses that require a more comprehensive logistics solution.

Limited coverage

2PL providers may have limited coverage areas, which can be a problem for businesses needing to move goods across long distances or borders.

Limited scalability

2PL providers may be unable to scale their services quickly to accommodate sudden increases in demand. This can be a problem for businesses that experience seasonal fluctuations in their logistics needs.

3PL Pros

Third-party logistics, or 3PL, can offer several advantages to businesses that require a comprehensive logistics solution. Here are some of them:

Comprehensive services

3PL providers offer services beyond transportation and storage, including packing, crating, inventory management, and warehousing. This can be helpful for businesses that need a one-stop shop for their logistics needs.

Expanded coverage

3PL providers often have a wider coverage area than 2PL providers, which can be helpful for businesses that need to move goods across long distances or borders.

Scalability

3PL providers can scale their services quickly to accommodate sudden increases in demand. This can be helpful for businesses that experience seasonal fluctuations in their logistics needs.

3PL Cons

Higher costs 

3PL providers may be more expensive than 2PL providers since they offer a more comprehensive range of services. This can be a disadvantage for businesses that have limited logistics needs and want to keep costs low.

Less direct control 

Since 3PL providers use their equipment and personnel, businesses may have less direct control over the transportation and storage of their goods. This can be a disadvantage for businesses with specific logistics operations requirements.

Less flexibility

3PL providers may be less flexible than 2PL providers regarding scheduling and delivery options. This can be a problem for businesses with time-sensitive deliveries or requiring specific routing.

2pl vs 3pl – Which is Right For Your Business?

If you’re wondering whether a third-party logistics (3PL) provider is right for you, there are a few things to consider. Firstly, consider the size and complexity of your supply chain. If you’re a small business with a simple supply chain, you may be able to manage it in-house. However, if your business is larger and your supply chain is complex, a 3PL may help you manage it more effectively.

Secondly, think about your budget. Hiring a 3PL can be expensive, so weighing the costs against the benefits is essential. Look at the services a 3PL can offer and compare them to the cost of managing your supply chain in-house. If a 3PL can provide cost savings and other benefits, it may be worth the investment.

Finally, consider the expertise and experience of the 3PL provider. Look for a provider with industry experience and an understanding of your specific supply chain needs. Check their references and ask for case studies to see how they have helped other businesses similar to yours.

Considering these factors, you can determine whether a 3PL is right for you and choose a provider to help you manage your supply chain effectively.

LatestFrom the blog

The latest industry news, interviews, technologies, and resources.

View all posts
View all posts
X
It's official: eHub has acquired ShipKey
Continue optimizing your shipping—and manage your fulfillment with ShipKey's robust platform.